“A church is not an arena.”
After a video of Julie Anne San Jose singing ABBA’s Dancing Queen during a Catholic mass surfaced on social media, it sparked backlash, with many criticizing the event for turning a holy mass into a mass concert. The singer wore a backless gown with a thigh-high slit—attire that some found too revealing for a church, a place where Catholics traditionally dress modestly out of respect for the sanctity of the space. To further the controversy, concert-style lighting surrounded the altar, adding to the impression of a performance venue rather than a religious service.
One netizen remarked, “Of all the places to sing, she chose a church!” The criticism isn’t solely directed at Julie Anne, who was likely following instructions, but rather at the Parish Pastoral Council (PPC) for allowing such an event. Even non-Catholics expressed that a different venue would have been more appropriate for this type of performance.
Moreover, many questioned the song choice. Dancing Queen has no connection to worship, which only fueled the backlash. Had a religious song been performed, the response might have been less intense. We must not treat a church like a concert hall; it’s a house of God, and the only ticket you need is for mass, confession, and a good old-fashioned prayer.
When it comes to sacred spaces, there’s a time for worship and a time for entertainment. Let’s keep the church a sanctuary for prayer, not a stage for ‘Holy Hilarity!’ Save the performances for talent shows and keep the altar for the altar-natives!
